Four thieves have stolen a gem, each claims they saw it last. Only one tells the truth, their alibi is the strongest. Who is it?

Category: Mystery · Difficulty: hard

Hint: Consider who might be less likely to draw attention.

Answer

The quiet one

Explanation

The quiet one tends to observe without embellishing their story, making them more credible.

This is a hard mystery riddle — a tricky one that takes a little thought. The answer is The quiet one.

More Mystery riddles

All Mystery riddles · Riddles with answers · Home